2024 Nominations clarifications #2
Apr. 21st, 2024 06:02 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
rarepairmod posting in ![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}
rarepairexchangeOur next nominations queries post is a big one. Please ensure you familiarise yourself with our rules and the nominations post.
Please remember to disambiguate your nominations!
*
We will not be accepting RPF nominations featuring controversial public figures. We apologise for the inconvenience this may cause, but we are not comfortable featuring fanworks about these people in our exchange.
This nomination will not be accepted.
*
We do not accept "All Media Types" nominations unless the fandom has been specified in our nominations post as the exception to this rule, or a participant makes a case for it. Please specify the single canon source you are nominating.
The following nominations have been moved to sit under "Baldur's Gate 3".
Please let us know if any of these characters do not belong to BG3. Thank you!
*
Can the nominator please edit their nominations to place these under "Marvel Cinematic Universe"? We've listed in our nominations post that MCU movies such as Captain Marvel need to be nominated under the MCU fandom tag.
*
We believe these nominations belong under "Crossover Fandom". Can the nominators please edit their nominations to place these ships under the correct fandom ("Crossover Fandom") or confirm that they belong in the nominated fandoms listed below. Please ensure you disambiguate your nominations.
If we do not hear back in 24 hours, these nominations will be rejected.
*
We want to merge Final Fantasy X and Final Fantasy X-2 nominations to sit under "Final Fantasy X Series". These are the ships accepted in the tagset that would be impacted by this:
Can the nominators (and those familiar with these games who intend to request them) please let us know if they see any issues with this? The mods are not familiar with FFX and we'd appreciate any guidance as to whether this may muddle sign-ups. (Please let us know if we need to include another fandom subcategory that's already accepted in the tagset to sit under "Final Fantasy X Series".)
Final Fantasy X-2 has been merged with Final Fantasy X Series.
We have also merged Valkyrie Profile: Lenneth with Valkyrie Profile Series.
*
Can we please get some guidance from our Tolkien and Rings of Power nominators? We have a few disambiguations that risk muddling sign-ups.
As it currently stands, we have the below in the tagset:
Can the nominators please let us know if:
the tags with the "(Tolkien)" disambiguation in "The Rings of Power (TV)" fandom need to be either corrected to reflect that they want the television version of these ships or if they need to be moved to the book fandom?
if "Galadriel (Tolkien)/Halbrand (The Rings of Power)"'s disambiguation needs to be corrected to "(Rings of Power)" and moved to sit under the TV show, or if it needs to be amended to "(Tolkien)" and remain where it is under the LOTR books?
if any of the ships are sitting under the wrong canon source and need to be moved?
Thank you, everyone! Please feel free to provide us with further guidance if you see errors in the tagset for any LOTR-related properties.
*
Please ensure your ships meet our exchange criteria of less than 250 works, be marked as completed, written in English, and filtered using otp: true filter.
*
We do not accept & nominations. This is stated in our rules and the nominations post. Please do not nominate & relationships—we will reject these outright.
The following have been rejected as they are not eligible for the exchange:
The nominators are welcome to re-nominate these as / ships.
*
Thank you for your help!
Please remember to disambiguate your nominations!
*
We will not be accepting RPF nominations featuring controversial public figures. We apologise for the inconvenience this may cause, but we are not comfortable featuring fanworks about these people in our exchange.
Political RPF - Russian 21st c.
Ramzan Kadyrov/Vladimir Putin (Political RPF)
This nomination will not be accepted.
*
We do not accept "All Media Types" nominations unless the fandom has been specified in our nominations post as the exception to this rule, or a participant makes a case for it. Please specify the single canon source you are nominating.
Babylon 5 & Related FandomsThese have been accepted as Babylon 5 (TV) nominations.
Marcus Cole/Susan Ivanova (Babylon 5)
Marcus Cole/Susan Ivanova/Talia Winters (Babylon 5)
Susan Ivanova/Talia Winters (Babylon 5)
Can the nominator please confirm the canon source? If we do not hear back from the nominator, these will be moved to "Babylon 5 (TV)".Hunger Games Series - All Media TypesThese have been moved to sit under books. The nominator has until nominations close to let us know the canon source they wanted to nominate these ships under.
Annie Cresta/Johanna Mason
Cinna/Finnick Odair
Gloss/Finnick Odair
Haymitch Abernathy/Cashmere
Haymitch Abernathy/Chaff
Haymitch Abernathy/Finnick Odair
Haymitch Abernathy/Hazelle Hawthorne
Katniss Everdeen/Madge Undersee
Katniss Everdeen/Peeta Mellark/Finnick Odair
Peeta Mellark/Finnick Odair
Can the nominator please confirm if this belongs under books or movies? If we do not hear back, these will be moved to sit under the books.
The Lord of the Rings - All Media Types
Diamond Took/Pippin Took
Frodo Baggins/Rose Cotton/Sam Gamgee
Merry Brandybuck/ÉowynCan the nominator please confirm the canon source—books, TV show or movies?These sit under "LOTR Movies".Star Wars - All Media TypesNominations closed: These have been moved to sit under Crossover Fandom.
Cal Kestis/Kanan Jarrus (Star Wars)
Han Solo/Kanan Jarrus (Star Wars)
CC-2224 | Cody/Darth Vader
Can the nominator please confirm if this belongs under Clone Wars or another branch of Star Wars?
The following nominations have been moved to sit under "Baldur's Gate 3".
Baldur's Gate (Video Games)
Ansur/Balduran (Baldur's Gate)
Dammon/Karlach (Baldur's Gate)
Gale/Karlach (Baldur's Gate)
Gale/Shadowheart (Baldur's Gate)
Halsin/Jaheira (Baldur's Gate)
Jaheira/Shadowheart (Baldur's Gate)
Karlach/Tav/Wyll (Baldur's Gate)
*
Can the nominator please edit their nominations to place these under "Marvel Cinematic Universe"? We've listed in our nominations post that MCU movies such as Captain Marvel need to be nominated under the MCU fandom tag.
Captain Marvel (2019)
Brunnhilde | Valkyrie/Carol Danvers
Carol Danvers/Soren/Talos
Carol Danvers/Talos
Carol Danvers/Yon-Rogg
Soren/Talos (Marvel)
These have been moved to sit under "MCU".
*
We believe these nominations belong under "Crossover Fandom". Can the nominators please edit their nominations to place these ships under the correct fandom ("Crossover Fandom") or confirm that they belong in the nominated fandoms listed below. Please ensure you disambiguate your nominations.
Austin Powers (Movies)
James Bond/Austin PowersPlease also add the correct disambiguation. Which James Bond are you after? (Please use the actor, i.e. "James Bond (Daniel Craig 007)".)This has been moved under "Crossover Fandom". James Bond has not been specified.
-
Law & Order: Criminal Intent
Olivia Benson/Alexandra EamesOlivia Benson is in Law & Order: SVU. Can the nominator please edit this nomination to sit under "Crossover Fandom" and add the disambiguation?This has been moved to "Crossover Fandom".
-
成化十四年 | The Sleuth of the Ming Dynasty (TV)
Tang fan/nie huaisang
Wang zhi/meng yao|jin guangyao
This has been accepted into "Crossover Fandom". Thank you!
-
山河令 | Word of Honor (TV 2021)
Meng Yao | Jin Guangyao/Xie Wang (Faraway Wanderers)
Nie Huaisang/Xie Wang (Faraway Wanderers)
If we do not hear back in 24 hours, these nominations will be rejected.
*
We want to merge Final Fantasy X and Final Fantasy X-2 nominations to sit under "Final Fantasy X Series". These are the ships accepted in the tagset that would be impacted by this:
Final Fantasy X Series
Auron/Rikku (FF X-2)
Auron/Braska/Jecht (Final Fantasy X Series)
Baralai/Gippal/Nooj/Paine (Final Fantasy X Series)
Lulu/Rikku/Wakka (Final Fantasy X Series)
Lulu/Yuna (Final Fantasy X Series)
Paine/Rikku/Yuna (Final Fantasy X Series)
Paine/Yuna (Final Fantasy X Series)
Rikku/Tidus (Final Fantasy X Series)
Rikku/Tidus/Yuna (Final Fantasy X Series)
Final Fantasy X-2
Auron/Rikku (FF X-2)
Auron/Braska/Jecht (Final Fantasy X Series)
Baralai/Gippal/Nooj/Paine (Final Fantasy X Series)
Lulu/Rikku/Wakka (Final Fantasy X Series)
Lulu/Yuna (Final Fantasy X Series)
Paine/Rikku/Yuna (Final Fantasy X Series)
Paine/Yuna (Final Fantasy X Series)
Rikku/Tidus (Final Fantasy X Series)
Rikku/Tidus/Yuna (Final Fantasy X Series)
Final Fantasy X-2 has been merged with Final Fantasy X Series.
We have also merged Valkyrie Profile: Lenneth with Valkyrie Profile Series.
*
Can we please get some guidance from our Tolkien and Rings of Power nominators? We have a few disambiguations that risk muddling sign-ups.
As it currently stands, we have the below in the tagset:
The Lord of the Rings - J. R. R. Tolkien
Arwen/Éowyn (Lord of the Rings)
Elladan/Elrohir (Lord of the Rings)
Éowyn/Lothíriel (Lord of the Rings)
Imrahil/Legolas (Lord of the Rings)
Théodred/Gríma Wormtongue (The Lord of the Rings - J. R. R. Tolkien)
Celeborn/Galadriel (Tolkien)
Celeborn/Galadriel/Sauron (Tolkien)
Celeborn/Glorfindel (Tolkien)
Celeborn/Sauron (Tolkien)
Galadriel (Tolkien)/Halbrand (The Rings of Power)
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (TV 2022)
Galadriel (Tolkien)/Halbrand (The Rings of Power)
Celeborn/Galadriel (Tolkien)
Celeborn/Galadriel/Sauron (Tolkien)
Celeborn/Sauron (Tolkien)
Thank you, everyone! Please feel free to provide us with further guidance if you see errors in the tagset for any LOTR-related properties.
*
Please ensure your ships meet our exchange criteria of less than 250 works, be marked as completed, written in English, and filtered using otp: true filter.
Law & Order: Criminal Intent
Alexandra Eames/Robert Goren
This ship has 256 works.
Miraculous Ladybug
Marinette Dupain-Cheng | Ladybug/Kagami Tsurugi
This ship has 253 works.
成化十四年 | The Sleuth of the Ming Dynasty (TV)
Sui Zhou/Tang Fan
This ship has 287 works.
*
We do not accept & nominations. This is stated in our rules and the nominations post. Please do not nominate & relationships—we will reject these outright.
The following have been rejected as they are not eligible for the exchange:
Law & Order: Criminal Intent
James Deakins & Alexandra Eames
Robert Goren & Original Female Character(s)
Ron Carver and Alexandra Eames
Zach Nichols & Danny Ross & Megan Wheeler
The Villains Of Valley View (TV)
Colby Madden | Flashform & Jake Madden | Chaos
Colby Madden | Flashform & Vic Madden | Kraniac
Hartley & Amy Madden | Havoc
Hartley & Amy Madden | Havoc & Eva Madden | Surge
Milo Covington & Amy Madden | Havoc
Andromeda (TV)
Beka Valentine & Rafe Valentine
Gabriel & Rommie (Andromeda)
Seamus Harper & Rommie
Trance Gemini & Rafe Valentine
Robotech The Macross Saga
Roy Fokker and Claudia Grant
Frasier (TV)
Frasier Crane & Martin Crane
Frasier Crane & Martin Crane & Niles Crane
Niles Crane & Daphne Moon
Niles Crane & Roz Doyle
Defiance (TV)
Amanda Rosewater & Kenya Rosewater
Irisa Nyira & Alak Tarr
Joshua Nolan & Amanda Rosewater
Joshua Nolan & Irisa Nyira
Tommy Lasalle & Joshua Nolan
Alice In Wonderland - Lewis Carroll
Alice & Caterpillar & Cheshire Cat & March Hare (Alice in Wonderland)
Alice & Cheshire Cat (Alice in Wonderland)
Alice & Mad Hatter (Alice in Wonderland)
Alice & Red Queen (Alice in Wonderland)
Mad Hatter & White Queen (Alice in Wonderland)
Tailchaser's Song - Tad Williams
Tailchaser's Song - Tad Williams
Bodies (TV 2023)
Esther Jankovsky & Charles Whiteman | Karl Weissman
세계관 최강자들이 내게 집착한다 | The Most Powerful Characters in the World are Obsessed with Me (Webcomic)
Alexander Duncan Michelio II & Dalia Pesteros (TMPitWaOwM)
Dune (Movies - Villeneuve)
Paul Atreides & Jessica
We Are Lady Parts (TV)
Amina Hussein & Saira
The nominators are welcome to re-nominate these as / ships.
*
Thank you for your help!
