Rare 🍐 Exchange (![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
rarepairmod) wrote in ![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
rarepairexchange2024-04-24 11:30 am
rarepairmod) wrote in rarepairexchange2024-04-24 11:30 am
Entry tags:
2024 Nominations clarifications #3
Please ensure you familiarise yourself with our rules and the nominations post before nominating. We still have outstanding queries from our second nominations post that we would appreciate nominators providing feedback on or editing their nominations so that they can be approved.
Please disambiguate your nominations and ensure that they are correct! Disambiguations are causing a few issues for us this year.
Thank you to everyone who has commented or emailed about duplicates, wandering tags, and disambiguations that can be firmer. We'll be responding to you as soon as possible. (Apologies if some of those queries are duplicated here.)
*
We do not accept "All Media Types" nominations unless the fandom has been specified in our nominations post as the exception to this rule, or a participant makes a case for it. Please specify the single canon source you are nominating.
If these nominations are not amended by the time nominations close, we will reject them.
*
We believe these nominations belong under "Crossover Fandom". Can the nominators please edit their nominations to place these ships under the correct fandom ("Crossover Fandom") or confirm that they belong in the nominated fandoms listed below. Please ensure you disambiguate your nominations.
If these nominations are not amended by the time nominations close, we will reject them.
*
The following nominations are approved, but we can't process them as they're over AO3's character limit! We were going to shorten these, but we worried doing so canonblind might lead them to lose their meaning to those familiar with the canons.
*
Can we please get confirmation if the following characters can be customised or if this is a genderbent nomination? We do not allow genderbent nominations.
These will be accepted as they are. Thank you!
*
Can we please get confirmation as to whether this nomination has a misspelling? (We have approved it but want to ensure it's spelt correctly.)
Thank you!
*
We do not accept & nominations. The following nominations have been rejected:
*
We do not accept inanimate objects as nominations.
*
We do not accept nominations that do not feature people.
*
The following nominations are over 250 works and have been rejected.
Please disambiguate your nominations and ensure that they are correct! Disambiguations are causing a few issues for us this year.
Thank you to everyone who has commented or emailed about duplicates, wandering tags, and disambiguations that can be firmer. We'll be responding to you as soon as possible. (Apologies if some of those queries are duplicated here.)
*
We do not accept "All Media Types" nominations unless the fandom has been specified in our nominations post as the exception to this rule, or a participant makes a case for it. Please specify the single canon source you are nominating.
Ivanhoe - All Media Types
Brian de Bois-Guilbert/Rebecca of YorkIs this film, TV, theatre, books? Please amend the fandom and add the disambiguation.This has been moved to "Ivanhoe - Walter Scott".
Star Wars - All Media Types
Armitage Hux/Jannah
Finn/Anakin Skywalker
Finn/Armitage Hux
Finn/Armitage Hux/Kylo Ren
Finn/Jannah (Star Wars)
Finn/Kylo Ren
Jannah/Rose Tico
Rey/Rose Tico
These nominations have been moved to sit under Star Wars Sequel Trilogy. Please let us know if any of the ships have been incorrectly placed in this subfandom.
A Song of Ice and Fire & Related Fandoms
Jojen Reed/Bran StarkPlease amend your nomination to specify whether this is from "Game of Thrones (TV)" or "A Song of Ice and Fire (Books)". Please add the correct disambiguation.This has been moved to "ASOIAF — George R.R. Martin".
Baldur's Gate (Video Games)
Aradin/Zevlor (Baldur's Gate)Please specify which video game. Is this Baldur's Gate 3?Thank you! This has been accepted under BG3.
Marvel Cinematic Universe
Edmund (Daredevil TV)/Matt Murdock
Lester | Benjamin "Dex" Poindexter/Matt MurdockPlease amend your nomination to "Daredevil (TV)" and add the disambiguation.This has been moved to "Daredevil".
PIERCE Tamora - Works
Dedicate Lark/Dedicate Rosethorn (Emelan)
Lalasa Isran/Tianine Plowman
Rizuka fa Dalach/Daja KisuboDo these all exist in the same universe? When checking, we saw that these ships came up with the subfandoms of Tortalls, The Immortals, etc. The mods are unfamiliar with this canon, so guidance would be greatly appreciated.Can the nominator please amend the fandom so Dedicate Lark/Dedicate Rosethorn is nominated under "Emelan - Tamora Pierce" and the other two ships are under "Tortall - Tamora Pierce"? If the nominator does not have space to nominate another fandom, please let us know and we will add it.These have been moved to "Emelan - Tamora Pierce" and "Tortall - Tamora Pierce".
If these nominations are not amended by the time nominations close, we will reject them.
*
We believe these nominations belong under "Crossover Fandom". Can the nominators please edit their nominations to place these ships under the correct fandom ("Crossover Fandom") or confirm that they belong in the nominated fandoms listed below. Please ensure you disambiguate your nominations.
Overwatch (Video Game)
Alexstrasza (Warcraft)/Hanzo ShimadaShould this be Warcraft/Overwatch? Please update the fandom to "Crossover Fandom" and add the disambiguation for Hanzo.This has been moved to "Crossover Fandom".
Marvel Cinematic Universe
Erik Lehnsherr/Wade Wilson
James "Bucky" Barnes/Wade Wilson
Steve Rogers/Wade Wilson
Tony Stark/Wade Wilson
Erik Lensherr and Wade Wilson are not a part of the MCU yet. Please amend your nomination and add disambiguations. We are happy to hear cases that Wade Wilson is prior to the release of Deadpool & Wolverine, but currently we do not consider him as such as his big MCU appearance is anticipated with this movie.
Marvel Cinematic Universe
Frank Castle/Wade Wilson
Frank Castle/Steve Rogers
James "Bucky" Barnes/Frank Castle
Frank Castle is not a part of the MCU but Marvel TV. Please amend his disambiguation to Daredevil or The Punisher. The other characters require a disambiguation. This nomination belongs under "Crossover Fandom".
Marvel Cinematic Universe
Steve Rogers/Claire Temple (MCU)
Claire Temple is not a part of the MCU but Marvel TV. Please amend her disambiguation to Daredevil or Luke Cage. Please add Steve Rogers' disambiguation. This nomination belongs under "Crossover Fandom".
Marvel Cinematic Universe
John Walker/Sam Wilson (Marvel)
John Walker/Sam Wilson (Marvel)
Lemar Hoskins/John Walker
Sam Wilson/Helmut Zemo
These nominations belong under "The Falcon and the Winter Soldier".Please amend your nomination to the correct fandom title and add the disambiguation.These have been moved to the TFATWS fandom.
Video Blogging RPF
Mark Fischbach/Ellie Goulding
Mark Fischbach/Ellie Goulding/Amy Nelson/Ethan Nestor
When we checked these tags, Ellie Goulding works were also tagged with "Music RPF". We believe Ellie belongs under "Music RPF", making this a crossover. Please amend your nomination and add the disambiguations.
Star Wars Sequel Trilogy
Finn/Anakin SkywalkerShould this be a crossover with the Original Trilogy? If so, please amend the fandom and add the disambiguation.This has been moved to "Crossover Fandom".
The Mandalorian (TV)
Din Djarin/Anakin Skywalker (Mandalorian)Should this be a crossover with the Original Trilogy? Wikipedia tells us Anakin Skywalker is only mentioned in The Mandalorian.Thank you!
The Grisha Trilogy - Leigh Bardugo
Kaz Brekker/Nikolai Lantsov (Six of Crows Grishaverse)Kaz Brekker does not appear in The Grisha Trilogy. This needs to be moved to sit under "Six of Crows Series - Leigh Bardugo" if you want Nikolai Lantsov as he appears in Crooked Kingdom or be nominated as "Crossover Fandom" if you want Nikolai Lantsov from The Grisha Trilogy. Please add disambiguations. (Please avoid using "Grishaverse" as a disambiguation.)This has been moved to "Six of Crows Series - Leigh Bardugo".
The Grisha Trilogy - Leigh Bardugo
Kaz Brekker/The Darkling | Aleksander Morozova (Six of Crows Grishaverse)The Darkling does not appear in Six of Crows and Kaz Brekker does not appear in The Grisha Trilogy. Please amend your nomination with "Crossover Fandom" as the fandom and disambiguate your nomination. (Please avoid using "Grishaverse" as a disambiguation.)This has been moved to "Crossover Fandom".
Black Sails
Israel Hands/John Silver (Black Sails)Israel Hands is a character from Our Flag Means Death. Please amend this to "Crossover Fandom" and add his disambiguation.Keeping as is, thank you!
The Terror (TV 2018)
Cornelius Hickey (The Terror)/Henry Drax (The North Water)
Cornelius Hickey (The Terror)/Patrick Sumner (The North Water)
Please amend the fandom to "Crossover Fandom". The disambiguations are fine as they are.
山河令 | Word of Honor (TV 2021)
Meng Yao|Jin Guangyao (The Untamed)/Xie Wang (Word of Honor)
Nie Huaisang (The Untamed)/Xie Wang (Word of Honor)
Please amend the fandom to "Crossover Fandom". The disambiguations are fine as they are.
If these nominations are not amended by the time nominations close, we will reject them.
*
The following nominations are approved, but we can't process them as they're over AO3's character limit! We were going to shorten these, but we worried doing so canonblind might lead them to lose their meaning to those familiar with the canons.
Digimon Adventure Zero Two | Digimon Adventure 02
Ichijouji Ken/Motomiya Daisuke/Takaishi Takeru/Yagami Hikari
Inoue Miyako | Yolei Inoue/Yagami Hikari | Kari Kamiya
Motomiya Daisuke | Davis Motomiya/Takaishi Takeru | T.K. Takaishi/Yagami Hikari | Kari Kamiya
If the nominator could edit these nominations to be shorter, we would greatly appreciate this. (Piping can be removed.)
Kill la Kill (Anime & Manga)
Gamagoori Ira/Inumuta Houka/Jakuzure Nonon/Kiyruuin Satsuki/Sanageyama Uzu
If the nominator could edit this nomination to be shorter, we would greatly appreciate this. (Remove surnames if you can.)
*
Fire Emblem: If | Fire Emblem: Fates
f!Corrin/Silas (Fire Emblem: Fates)
Fire Emblem: Fuukasetsugetsu | Fire Emblem: Three Houses
m!Byleth/Gatekeeper (Fire Emblem: Three Houses)
These will be accepted as they are. Thank you!
*
僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia (Anime & Manga)
Komori Konoku/Kuroiro Shihai (MHA)
Thank you!
*
We do not accept & nominations. The following nominations have been rejected:
Star Trek: Enterprise
Crew of the Starship Enterprise & Original Character(s)
Jonathan Archer & Charles "Trip" Tucker III
Jonathan Archer & Malcolm Reed
Malcolm Reed & T'Pol
*
We do not accept inanimate objects as nominations.
Inception (2010)
Saito (inception)/Saito's Carpet
*
We do not accept nominations that do not feature people.
Historical RPF
Alexandros III of Macedon | Alexander the Great/Boukephalas | Bucephalas the Horse (Hist RPF)
*
The following nominations are over 250 works and have been rejected.
Star Trek: Enterprise
Malcolm Reed/Charles "Trip" Tucker III
This ship has 1,757 works.
The Vampire Diaries (TV)
Alaric Saltzman/Damon Salvatore (The Vampire Diaries)
This ship has 278 works.